In the charming community of Goodland, Florida, there’s a bright turquoise building with a name that perfectly captures both its coastal vibe and no-nonsense approach to seafood: Crabby Lady.

Join me on a sun-soaked road trip along Florida’s coast to uncover the best (and most surprising) Key lime pie cafes.

The two hotels, which opened this year, become the fourth and fifth Seattle-area properties to be awarded the honor.